The newest registered user is Pancho83
Our users have posted a total of 205167 messages in 31957 subjects
Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
Page 4 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
MyLittleSecret- TxSoccer Poster
- Posts : 14
Join date : 2012-07-12
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
MyLittleSecret wrote:Our coach has been at this a long time. He has trained coaches, referees and continues his love of teaching the girls soccer. Me tells the parents to cheer for the girls and keep quiet about the referee's calls. His point is that nothing good comes complaining about the referees. They are doing their best and none of the complaints will will get you anything but in trouble. It makes for little drama in the stands, but we do not have to worry about our DD's being penalized for our actions. Our only topic of discussion is usually how loud the parents of the other team are.
Wtf?
Blank77- Original Supporting Member
- Posts : 927
Points : 5692
Join date : 2011-05-15
Location : Obviously at a different IP than last time
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
Blank77 wrote:MyLittleSecret wrote:Our coach has been at this a long time. He has trained coaches, referees and continues his love of teaching the girls soccer. Me tells the parents to cheer for the girls and keep quiet about the referee's calls. His point is that nothing good comes complaining about the referees. They are doing their best and none of the complaints will will get you anything but in trouble. It makes for little drama in the stands, but we do not have to worry about our DD's being penalized for our actions. Our only topic of discussion is usually how loud the parents of the other team are.
Wtf?
Me tells the parents too.
LC57- TxSoccer Lurker
- Posts : 8
Points : 4390
Join date : 2012-03-30
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
coachr- TxSoccer Author
- Posts : 989
Points : 5800
Join date : 2011-04-01
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
The following language has been added to Section IV LHGCL Play, Sub-Section H of the League Rules:
9. 9. Abandonments.
a. Abandonments are defined as games ended short of completion by either a referee or LHGCL Official for misbehavior or misconduct by any party. If a game is properly abandoned, the offending team (to be determined at the sole discretion of LHGCL) will receive 0 (zero) points/goals regardless of score. The non-offending team will receive at least one point/goal if they have not scored or number of goals scored whichever is greater.
b. The penalty for an abandoned game for the offending team is a $500 (five hundred dollar) fine (cash or money order only) and 1 (one) point deduction from standing points. The team will not be able to play until the fine is received by the league. League decision is final
midfieldersdad- TxSoccer Postmaster
- Posts : 237
Points : 4936
Join date : 2011-06-15
Location : Winning the game at the 50/50
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
scoop99 wrote:Hook It wrote:Blank77 wrote:Xara wrote:The referee got the call correct. The player in white was moving the ball to the left and looked like she was preparing to make a pass to her teammate on the left wing. A player in red behind the girl with the ball clips the player's right foot with her knee. You can then see the player in white trip over her own left leg since the path of her right foot was changed by the trip. That was the foul and the ref was exactly where he needed to be to see it. As the white player is falling, a different red defender moves to clear the ball and may have even kicked the player in white unintentionally.
But what's more crazy is the reaction that the coach of the red team allowed from his players. You can hear one or more of them loudly deriding the referee from the bench. One would expect the coach to question the call, but the girls on the bench? And with so much attitude? It is therefore easy to assume that many of the red players on the field were being flippant if that this the type of tolerance allowed by the coach. And my guess would be the parents were equally mouthy.
Good job, ref.
I watched it again, and I don't think the girl was ever touched. I think she just went down and I can see the case for AFC being upset...BUT, that type of call is made all the time. One thing I thought was odd, he seemed concerned about who was kicking it - looked like he asked white several times who was taking the kick? Why does that matter, place the ball - walk it off - and let play resume.
Agreed, that is what I thought until I saw the slow-mo at the end of the video, looks like the foot was just barely clipped causing the trip. Anyway you are correct, almost every game has a few bad/missed calls. It took a long time to sort it out which I am sure added to the frustration.
The HD Video is great - I want one, although I don't have the patience to do it at the game, no way no how!
This video is getting scrutinized more than the Zapruder film! It's my opinion that she was not touched and from the manner she fell...it appeared to be more of a drop than a reaction to being tripped.
You must have been one of the NFL replacement refs. The foot is clipped. It looks completely inadvertent but it is clipped and she went down. Unlucky, but still a foul.
nukem- TxSoccer Author
- Posts : 904
Points : 6006
Join date : 2010-05-06
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
midfieldersdad wrote:This just in from the LHGCL NewsMail #5
The following language has been added to Section IV LHGCL Play, Sub-Section H of the League Rules:
9. 9. Abandonments.
a. Abandonments are defined as games ended short of completion by either a referee or LHGCL Official for misbehavior or misconduct by any party. If a game is properly abandoned, the offending team (to be determined at the sole discretion of LHGCL) will receive 0 (zero) points/goals regardless of score. The non-offending team will receive at least one point/goal if they have not scored or number of goals scored whichever is greater.
b. The penalty for an abandoned game for the offending team is a $500 (five hundred dollar) fine (cash or money order only) and 1 (one) point deduction from standing points. The team will not be able to play until the fine is received by the league. League decision is final
Ouch
nukem- TxSoccer Author
- Posts : 904
Points : 6006
Join date : 2010-05-06
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
That's severe.nukem wrote:midfieldersdad wrote:This just in from the LHGCL NewsMail #5
The following language has been added to Section IV LHGCL Play, Sub-Section H of the League Rules:
9. 9. Abandonments.
a. Abandonments are defined as games ended short of completion by either a referee or LHGCL Official for misbehavior or misconduct by any party. If a game is properly abandoned, the offending team (to be determined at the sole discretion of LHGCL) will receive 0 (zero) points/goals regardless of score. The non-offending team will receive at least one point/goal if they have not scored or number of goals scored whichever is greater.
b. The penalty for an abandoned game for the offending team is a $500 (five hundred dollar) fine (cash or money order only) and 1 (one) point deduction from standing points. The team will not be able to play until the fine is received by the league. League decision is final
Ouch
bigtex75081- TxSoccer Author
- Posts : 582
Points : 5116
Join date : 2011-11-08
Age : 46
Location : I'm right behind you.
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
bigtex75081 wrote:That's severe.nukem wrote:midfieldersdad wrote:This just in from the LHGCL NewsMail #5
The following language has been added to Section IV LHGCL Play, Sub-Section H of the League Rules:
9. 9. Abandonments.
a. Abandonments are defined as games ended short of completion by either a referee or LHGCL Official for misbehavior or misconduct by any party. If a game is properly abandoned, the offending team (to be determined at the sole discretion of LHGCL) will receive 0 (zero) points/goals regardless of score. The non-offending team will receive at least one point/goal if they have not scored or number of goals scored whichever is greater.
b. The penalty for an abandoned game for the offending team is a $500 (five hundred dollar) fine (cash or money order only) and 1 (one) point deduction from standing points. The team will not be able to play until the fine is received by the league. League decision is final
Ouch
...and appropriate.
Guest- Guest
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
nukem wrote:scoop99 wrote:Hook It wrote:Blank77 wrote:Xara wrote:The referee got the call correct. The player in white was moving the ball to the left and looked like she was preparing to make a pass to her teammate on the left wing. A player in red behind the girl with the ball clips the player's right foot with her knee. You can then see the player in white trip over her own left leg since the path of her right foot was changed by the trip. That was the foul and the ref was exactly where he needed to be to see it. As the white player is falling, a different red defender moves to clear the ball and may have even kicked the player in white unintentionally.
But what's more crazy is the reaction that the coach of the red team allowed from his players. You can hear one or more of them loudly deriding the referee from the bench. One would expect the coach to question the call, but the girls on the bench? And with so much attitude? It is therefore easy to assume that many of the red players on the field were being flippant if that this the type of tolerance allowed by the coach. And my guess would be the parents were equally mouthy.
Good job, ref.
I watched it again, and I don't think the girl was ever touched. I think she just went down and I can see the case for AFC being upset...BUT, that type of call is made all the time. One thing I thought was odd, he seemed concerned about who was kicking it - looked like he asked white several times who was taking the kick? Why does that matter, place the ball - walk it off - and let play resume.
Agreed, that is what I thought until I saw the slow-mo at the end of the video, looks like the foot was just barely clipped causing the trip. Anyway you are correct, almost every game has a few bad/missed calls. It took a long time to sort it out which I am sure added to the frustration.
The HD Video is great - I want one, although I don't have the patience to do it at the game, no way no how!
This video is getting scrutinized more than the Zapruder film! It's my opinion that she was not touched and from the manner she fell...it appeared to be more of a drop than a reaction to being tripped.
You must have been one of the NFL replacement refs. The foot is clipped. It looks completely inadvertent but it is clipped and she went down. Unlucky, but still a foul.
Nuke'em, That was my original post while watching on my phone...later I watched on my PC and 'reversed my previous ruling' ...and posted my reversal!
Yes I admitted I was wrong....and I was one of the NFL replacement refs...you may have seen me toss my hat aside in the Tampa Bay game.
Guest- Guest
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
If you had to watch the video several times even in instant replay then imagine the referee having to make that call within a split second and no replay. This is an excellent video to prove a point about people seeing things differently. We have parents on the sideline 40 to 60 yards away calling it one way. But you have 50 parents looking at the video and still can't get the call correct. Let's start giving the ref a benefit of the doubt.
Good job Mr. Ref!
Its Me- TxSoccer Author
- Posts : 951
Points : 6481
Join date : 2009-07-20
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
scoop99 wrote:nukem wrote:scoop99 wrote:Hook It wrote:Blank77 wrote:Xara wrote:The referee got the call correct. The player in white was moving the ball to the left and looked like she was preparing to make a pass to her teammate on the left wing. A player in red behind the girl with the ball clips the player's right foot with her knee. You can then see the player in white trip over her own left leg since the path of her right foot was changed by the trip. That was the foul and the ref was exactly where he needed to be to see it. As the white player is falling, a different red defender moves to clear the ball and may have even kicked the player in white unintentionally.
But what's more crazy is the reaction that the coach of the red team allowed from his players. You can hear one or more of them loudly deriding the referee from the bench. One would expect the coach to question the call, but the girls on the bench? And with so much attitude? It is therefore easy to assume that many of the red players on the field were being flippant if that this the type of tolerance allowed by the coach. And my guess would be the parents were equally mouthy.
Good job, ref.
I watched it again, and I don't think the girl was ever touched. I think she just went down and I can see the case for AFC being upset...BUT, that type of call is made all the time. One thing I thought was odd, he seemed concerned about who was kicking it - looked like he asked white several times who was taking the kick? Why does that matter, place the ball - walk it off - and let play resume.
Agreed, that is what I thought until I saw the slow-mo at the end of the video, looks like the foot was just barely clipped causing the trip. Anyway you are correct, almost every game has a few bad/missed calls. It took a long time to sort it out which I am sure added to the frustration.
The HD Video is great - I want one, although I don't have the patience to do it at the game, no way no how!
This video is getting scrutinized more than the Zapruder film! It's my opinion that she was not touched and from the manner she fell...it appeared to be more of a drop than a reaction to being tripped.
You must have been one of the NFL replacement refs. The foot is clipped. It looks completely inadvertent but it is clipped and she went down. Unlucky, but still a foul.
Nuke'em, That was my original post while watching on my phone...later I watched on my PC and 'reversed my previous ruling' ...and posted my reversal!
Yes I admitted I was wrong....and I was one of the NFL replacement refs...you may have seen me toss my hat aside in the Tampa Bay game.
I was just giving you a hard time. I haven't posted in a while and your post was the only one I could come up with a half witty response.
nukem- TxSoccer Author
- Posts : 904
Points : 6006
Join date : 2010-05-06
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
midfieldersdad wrote:This just in from the LHGCL NewsMail #5
The following language has been added to Section IV LHGCL Play, Sub-Section H of the League Rules:
9. 9. Abandonments.
a. Abandonments are defined as games ended short of completion by either a referee or LHGCL Official for misbehavior or misconduct by any party. If a game is properly abandoned, the offending team (to be determined at the sole discretion of LHGCL) will receive 0 (zero) points/goals regardless of score. The non-offending team will receive at least one point/goal if they have not scored or number of goals scored whichever is greater.
b. The penalty for an abandoned game for the offending team is a $500 (five hundred dollar) fine (cash or money order only) and 1 (one) point deduction from standing points. The team will not be able to play until the fine is received by the league. League decision is final
100% correct call, even if he may not have explained it well. Like it our not, the foot got clipped and the foul was properly called. You can't give that DD an opportunity just outside the box because she's got a boot.
Soccer Talker- TxSoccer Poster
- Posts : 79
Points : 5220
Join date : 2010-04-21
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
bigtex75081 wrote:The players on the field can be carded but the people on the sidelines cannot. The referee can show the people on the sideline the card as a symbol but it doesn't mean anything to them. The only thing a referee can do to the people off the field is eject them and stop the game as everyone waits for the offenders to be escorted off the field. That doesn't require a card though.
This would be an exciting hearing to attend.
Winning goal? I thought the final was 3-0 Diamonds?
Soccer Talker- TxSoccer Poster
- Posts : 79
Points : 5220
Join date : 2010-04-21
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
SoccerTalker wrote:midfieldersdad wrote:This just in from the LHGCL NewsMail #5
The following language has been added to Section IV LHGCL Play, Sub-Section H of the League Rules:
9. 9. Abandonments.
a. Abandonments are defined as games ended short of completion by either a referee or LHGCL Official for misbehavior or misconduct by any party. If a game is properly abandoned, the offending team (to be determined at the sole discretion of LHGCL) will receive 0 (zero) points/goals regardless of score. The non-offending team will receive at least one point/goal if they have not scored or number of goals scored whichever is greater.
b. The penalty for an abandoned game for the offending team is a $500 (five hundred dollar) fine (cash or money order only) and 1 (one) point deduction from standing points. The team will not be able to play until the fine is received by the league. League decision is final
100% correct call, even if he may not have explained it well. Like it our not, the foot got clipped and the foul was properly called. You can't give that DD an opportunity just outside the box because she's got a boot.
Less Filling!
Tastes Great!
midfieldersdad- TxSoccer Postmaster
- Posts : 237
Points : 4936
Join date : 2011-06-15
Location : Winning the game at the 50/50
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
SoccerTalker wrote:bigtex75081 wrote:The players on the field can be carded but the people on the sidelines cannot. The referee can show the people on the sideline the card as a symbol but it doesn't mean anything to them. The only thing a referee can do to the people off the field is eject them and stop the game as everyone waits for the offenders to be escorted off the field. That doesn't require a card though.
This would be an exciting hearing to attend.
Winning goal? I thought the final was 3-0 Diamonds?
Apparently the game was recorded as a forfeit due to the abandonment.
__________________________________________________
When you can snatch the pebbles from my hand Grasshopper, it will be time for you to leave.
JeffM- TxSoccer Author
- Posts : 963
Points : 6495
Join date : 2009-05-20
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
"In response to these unfortunate events, the Board of Directors of the Lake Highlands Girls Classic League voted to enact a new rule regarding abandonment. The following language has been added to Section IV LHGCL Play, Sub-Section H of the League Rules:
9. 9. Abandonments.
a. Abandonments are defined as games ended short of completion by either a referee or LHGCL Official for misbehavior or misconduct by any party. If a game is properly abandoned, the offending team (to be determined at the sole discretion of LHGCL) will receive 0 (zero) points/goals regardless of score. The non-offending team will receive at least one point/goal if they have not scored or number of goals scored whichever is greater.
b. The penalty for an abandoned game for the offending team is a $500 (five hundred dollar) fine (cash or money order only) and 1 (one) point deduction from standing points. The team will not be able to play until the fine is received by the league. League decision is final"
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
justpeachy- TxSoccer Poster
- Posts : 88
Points : 4885
Join date : 2011-03-01
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
Blank77- Original Supporting Member
- Posts : 927
Points : 5692
Join date : 2011-05-15
Location : Obviously at a different IP than last time
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
"Disciplinary issues continue to be a serious problem for our league. So far, just a few months into our soccer year, we have seen 3 games abandoned. There are many reasons for an abandoned game, none of them good. There is one constant though, and that is that these abandonments are being caused by adults, not players. It is so unfortunate that the actions of certain individuals may have such a negative effect on these young ladies.
In response to these unfortunate events, the Board of Directors of the Lake Highlands Girls Classic League voted to enact a new rule regarding abandonment. The following language has been added to Section IV LHGCL Play, Sub-Section H of the League Rules:"
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
David May just let out a breath when he read your post. He was looking at thousands of dollars in fines if the rule was retroactive.Blank77 wrote:If the events caused the additional rule, which I highly doubt, they couldn't go back in time to enforce rules that didn't exist at the time the even occured. That is like saying it is illegal to drive a car until you are 18 and going back and arresting all of us that drove at 16 before this was a law.
coachr- TxSoccer Author
- Posts : 989
Points : 5800
Join date : 2011-04-01
Re: Can an entire Team recieve a YELLOW/ RED Card?
Blank77 wrote:If the events caused the additional rule, which I highly doubt, they couldn't go back in time to enforce rules that didn't exist at the time the even occured. That is like saying it is illegal to drive a car until you are 18 and going back and arresting all of us that drove at 16 before this was a law.
I think the additional rule was partially caused by this event but you are correct and my bad on assuming retroactivity - not sure what I was thinking there.
justpeachy- TxSoccer Poster
- Posts : 88
Points : 4885
Join date : 2011-03-01
Page 4 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
» My dd got her first yellow card!!
» Dues!?! Doctors orders Out entire season
» Mothers Day Weekend Tournament Predictions
» Tournament red card