Latest topics
TOP TEN 08’ BOYS TEAMSToday at 4:35 amTxRMC
U12 DA cost?Today at 3:00 amBadknees
GEE THANKS DTSC FALL FESTIVAL!?Today at 2:31 amupper95
2018 America's Red, White & Blue CupYesterday at 10:31 pmLiverpool Tournaments
Game of the WeekYesterday at 10:15 pmCATX
TOURNAMENT: UPPER 90 CHALLENGE - Nov. 30-Dec. 2, 2018Yesterday at 3:46 pmU90C
Tournament upset alertYesterday at 12:04 amCheckpoint Charlie
03 DT Fall Festival 17/11/2018, 6:16 pmAnt_Knee
League Challenge Cup discussion17/11/2018, 3:17 amteddykgb
Out of Control16/11/2018, 9:33 pmCornydogonastick
06 Boys looking for a free or half price tourney in December16/11/2018, 9:09 pmEFC-Soccer
07 Boys Teams - Round Rock Open (Dec. 7-9)16/11/2018, 7:35 pmU90C
03 Boys Teams - Upper 90 Challenge (Nov. 30-Dec. 2)16/11/2018, 7:04 pmU90C
Dfeeters Thanksgiving Showcase16/11/2018, 6:52 pmcanaryman
12 Girls Teams - Upper 90 Challenge (Nov. 30-Dec. 2)16/11/2018, 6:21 pmU90C
09 Girls Teams - Upper 90 Challenge (Nov. 30-Dec. 2)16/11/2018, 4:56 pmU90C
07 Girls Teams - Upper 90 Challenge (Nov. 30-Dec. 2)16/11/2018, 4:55 pmU90C
11 Girls Teams - Upper 90 Challenge (Nov. 30-Dec. 2)16/11/2018, 4:54 pmU90C
10 Boys Teams - Upper 90 Challenge (Nov. 30-Dec. 2)16/11/2018, 4:52 pmU90C
Looking for guest players! 16/11/2018, 2:28 pmpingo99
Solar East Williamson 09 JCL16/11/2018, 11:50 amSolarEastForney
05 Girls Teams - Upper 90 Challenge (Nov. 30-Dec. 2)15/11/2018, 11:34 pmU90C
12 Boys Teams - Upper 90 Challenge (Nov. 30-Dec. 2)15/11/2018, 11:32 pmU90C
07 Boys Teams - Upper 90 Challenge (Nov. 30-Dec. 2)15/11/2018, 11:30 pmU90C
05 Boys Teams - Upper 90 Challenge (Nov. 30-Dec. 2)15/11/2018, 11:28 pmU90C
Log in

I forgot my password

Be An Athletic Supporter!
Donate and get this nifty tag!

Statistics
We have 12737 registered users
The newest registered user is KALRP11

Our users have posted a total of 183674 messages in 24439 subjects

03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Go down

03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by NoFanOfDrama on 12/6/2015, 3:28 pm

The more I think about this 2 division 03 group, the more I don't like it.

D1 is supposed to be for the best of the best. Clearly there were a couple of teams that were outclassed and the system was going to relegate them down with 2 potential contenders moving up.

When you look at all sports, teams in a conference play each other 2x per year. With the teams as evenly matched as they were in D1 (save the bottom two and the top team), playing 2x per year just makes the most sense.

Now we have fewer games and there are teams in D1 which simply don't belong there, and teams in D2 that don't belong their either. Period. End of story.

Some will say "There was no other way because of the incomplete season." Bull crap. It would have been very easy to use goal differential to weight the games played and determine a value per game. Then you weight the total number of games played against the total possible, and bingo, you have your formula for determining D1, D2, D3.

There are three clear levels of play in this league - LHGCL isn't doing ANYONE any favors by collapsing it down while there are still this many teams competing.

LHGCL got lazy - that's all there is to it. Perhaps there was political pressure to give clubs the ability to recruit by saying "LHGCL D1 Bye." Certainly, there are teams in D1 that should not be able to make that claim.

After this upcoming debacle of a season, LHGCL will realize how ridiculous this was and will go back to 3 divisions. I just wish they had the guts to admit collapsing to 2 divisions is a HUGE mistake and correct it before the next kickoff.

avatar
NoFanOfDrama
TxSoccer Postmaster
TxSoccer Postmaster

Posts : 217
Points : 2380
Join date : 2013-01-04

Back to top Go down

Re: 03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by ArnoldZiffel on 12/6/2015, 6:20 pm

I read the subject line & thought you would talk about the health of the players.
When there's a disparity between competing teams, frustration fouls occur, injuries happen due to physical over matching. The refs are going to have their hands full with this mess.
Maybe half the games will be even contests. The other half ... why bother?
Seeing Keegan get beat down last year was bad. This will be worse.
avatar
ArnoldZiffel
TxSoccer Lurker
TxSoccer Lurker

Posts : 9
Points : 1489
Join date : 2014-10-31
Location : Hooterville

Back to top Go down

Re: 03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by NoFanOfDrama on 12/6/2015, 6:36 pm

The reasons are numerous, and what you brought up are all very good points.

We need to all ask our coaches/organizations to appeal to LHGCL to change their structure. Otherwise you will have lower caliber players cheap shotting when they are getting their clocks cleaned.
avatar
NoFanOfDrama
TxSoccer Postmaster
TxSoccer Postmaster

Posts : 217
Points : 2380
Join date : 2013-01-04

Back to top Go down

Re: 03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by herradura on 12/6/2015, 6:45 pm

OK, NFOD, I've got no dog in this fight, but I'll bite. You said "clearly a couple of teams that were outclassed" and "Certainly, there are teams in D1 that should not be able to make that claim".

Ok, we all agree on Keegan - who else was outclassed? - DT Scott? Fever? Hilton? I think each would argue that they played well in D1 a majority of the time and should have had a legitimate shot at staying in the division.

Long story short, the best will rise to the top, the rest will settle where they should by the time the 3 division system is re-implemented. I personally think it will make the season more interesting and also give quality players opportunities to stay with their current team and still get to play at a higher level.
avatar
herradura
TxSoccer Author
TxSoccer Author

Posts : 673
Points : 2858
Join date : 2013-02-17
Location : At counseling "talking through" the desire to instigate forum drama

Back to top Go down

Re: 03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by NoFanOfDrama on 12/6/2015, 6:56 pm

herradura wrote:OK, NFOD, I've got no dog in this fight, but I'll bite. You said "clearly a couple of teams that were outclassed" and "Certainly, there are teams in D1 that should not be able to make that claim".

Ok, we all agree on Keegan - who else was outclassed? - DT Scott? Fever? Hilton? I think each would argue that they played well in D1 a majority of the time and should have had a legitimate shot at staying in D1.

Long story short, the best will rise to the top, the rest will settle where they should by the time the 3 division system is re-implemented. I personally think it will make the season more interesting and also give players opportunities to stay with their current team and still get to play at a higher level.

So based on this, everyone should also get a trophy. How about ice cream socials after every game? Why not just make one big group and draw straws randomly.

The privilege of playing at this level is exactly that, a privilege. These teams work hard to get here, why diminish that accomplishment?

Conversely, it's bad enough to get your butt handed to you in a tournament by one of these D1 teams, to have to play them in the regular season is just adding to the misery. You can wave the "it's good for them to play harder teams" flag all you want, but I can guarantee you that Keegan didn't like getting trounced every game and that beating did very little to develope them.

You even said yourself, when this settles back to a 3 team tier, it will be better. THAT is my point! Why do we have to go through this lunacy?
avatar
NoFanOfDrama
TxSoccer Postmaster
TxSoccer Postmaster

Posts : 217
Points : 2380
Join date : 2013-01-04

Back to top Go down

Re: 03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by jsullivan81 on 12/6/2015, 7:04 pm

Outside of Keegan, who will have a difficult time sustaining a season against the other D1 teams?

jsullivan81
TxSoccer Postmaster
TxSoccer Postmaster

Posts : 419
Points : 2620
Join date : 2012-11-19

Back to top Go down

Re: 03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by Barca on 12/6/2015, 7:22 pm

Actually, two woud have gone down and only one would have moved up into a 9 team D1 division.

I would like to see us play the 14 games in the fall and then split the division with the last remaining games taking place in a 3 division format in the Spring. That would be a maximum of 24 games for Div 2 & 3; 23 for D-1. More games, yes, but that would make up for the lost games this past season. Format only sucks if you are one of the "would have been" D1 teams that is currently losing a high volume of players to other teams. Couple of Titanics out there shuffling the chairs on a sinking ship.


Last edited by Barca on 12/6/2015, 7:48 pm; edited 1 time in total
avatar
Barca
TxSoccer Postmaster
TxSoccer Postmaster

Posts : 365
Points : 2461
Join date : 2013-04-01

Back to top Go down

Re: 03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by Triumph FC on 12/6/2015, 7:39 pm

We have written to Lake Highlands to complain bitterly about what they have done. To just say top 5 up to D1 and bottom 5 down to D3 (we can dress it up but its relegation regardless of LH saying D2)is so wrong. Our Triumph team and the Dfeeters were 2 of the 3 teams who played the least amount. We had 2 of the bottom 3 teams to play. Of course we could have lost them but we also could have won them. We earnt the right to play in D2 but now LH have decided to put us in D3 for playing less games (still had 5 to play) As a previous poster put...they took the easy way out. In the the 03's I'm sorry but it was nearly all done and dusted and I don't think anyone would complain if they promoted and relegated teams when the league canceled the rest of the season
Questions still to be answered
We lost 5 games so cheaper league fees?
We are playing 4 less this year so cheaper league fees?
5 + 4 = 9 games nearly a season they owe us, nearly a season so cheaper league fees?
Field maintenance fee, surely they won't ask for this! What maintenance did they do, we didn't use them!
avatar
Triumph FC
TxSoccer Sponsor
TxSoccer Sponsor

Posts : 1525
Points : 4893
Join date : 2010-06-20

http://www.triumphfc.org

Back to top Go down

Re: 03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by Koba on 12/6/2015, 7:42 pm

NFOD, I'd venture to say that FWFC Black, LP Rush, Sting Flanny will give your team all they can handle.
avatar
Koba
TxSoccer Postmaster
TxSoccer Postmaster

Posts : 115
Points : 1692
Join date : 2014-07-31

Back to top Go down

Re: 03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by Triumph FC on 12/6/2015, 7:46 pm

Then why aren't we in D1. We just beat FWFC Black?
See that's why it's so wrong!
Of course we didn't earn the right to be in D1 but we also didn't earn the right to be in D3 either
avatar
Triumph FC
TxSoccer Sponsor
TxSoccer Sponsor

Posts : 1525
Points : 4893
Join date : 2010-06-20

http://www.triumphfc.org

Back to top Go down

Re: 03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by NoFanOfDrama on 12/6/2015, 7:51 pm

Koba wrote:NFOD, I'd venture to say that FWFC Black, LP Rush, Sting Flanny will give your team all they can handle.

LOL...you are completely off your rocker.
avatar
NoFanOfDrama
TxSoccer Postmaster
TxSoccer Postmaster

Posts : 217
Points : 2380
Join date : 2013-01-04

Back to top Go down

Re: 03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by BurnOnYou on 13/6/2015, 7:26 pm

Doesn't have to be goal differential.
Not my work, but elegant in its simplicity. In D1
154 total games when wins and losses for each team.  Divide by 10 and you get 15.4 games.  Take points earned by each team and divide that by number of games that team played and you get a points per game number for each team.  Multiply that points per game for each team by 15.4 and you get a points per team when extrapolated against the 15.4 games.
In D1 when this was done it showed a minimal difference in rankings.  By the way Herradura,  fever won one game in the spring against Keagan and Texans had a very steep hill to climb, needing 6 points with 4 games and having to play most of the class of the division in their final games.
LHGCL wimped out and took the path of least resistance and intestinal fortitude.  Don't think they put any real thought in how to address this issue...

BurnOnYou
TxSoccer Postmaster
TxSoccer Postmaster

Posts : 108
Points : 1748
Join date : 2014-05-29

Back to top Go down

Re: 03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by GrandTXSoccer on 15/6/2015, 4:03 pm

Personally I would have just maxed out point for all of the remaining games. So DI would end like this:

1. Gold
2. Sting G
3. LP Elite/FCD
4. FCD Pre
5. Cosmos
6. DT South
7. Sting H
8. DT Scott
9. Fever
10. LP Keegan

Fever and Scott tie with points but they played H2H earlier in the year so Scott gets to stay and Fever and Keegan drop.

In DII -

1. FWFC
2. LP Rush
3. Sting F
4. FCD Red
5. Andro
6. DFeet
7. Triumph
8. Texans
9. LP Barnes
10. FCD Blue

FWFC moves up, LP Barnes and FCD Blue move down.

DII

1. Sting Sanchez
2. Odyssey
3. Sparta
4. Mustang
5. Mutiny
6. Sting Skaife
7. Solar
8. Solar Royal
9. TX Lightning
10. Warriors

Sting Sanchez to DII, Odyssey, Sparta, Mustangs, and Mutiny all stay DIII. Sting Skaife, Solar, Solar, TX Lightning and Warriors must re-qualify if they want to.

Given the jacked up number of games played this seems like a pretty fair option. It really didn't change much, a few teams are ranked higher than when they finished but I after the way the schedules played out I hope no one is going around bragging about where they finished in leagues where there were a 3 to 5 games played difference. It is NTX soccer so I'm sure there's some folks out there saying that stuff though. This solution literally took me 15 minutes while waiting on hold for customer service to pick up the phone.

GrandTXSoccer
TxSoccer Author
TxSoccer Author

Posts : 707
Points : 3320
Join date : 2011-11-09

Back to top Go down

Re: 03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by herradura on 15/6/2015, 4:50 pm

GrandTX for LHCL President 2016!
avatar
herradura
TxSoccer Author
TxSoccer Author

Posts : 673
Points : 2858
Join date : 2013-02-17
Location : At counseling "talking through" the desire to instigate forum drama

Back to top Go down

Re: 03 Healthier with 3 Divisions

Post by blastit on 15/6/2015, 6:07 pm

I completely agree with those 3 divisions!

blastit
TxSoccer Poster
TxSoccer Poster

Posts : 66
Points : 2385
Join date : 2012-07-25

Back to top Go down

Back to top


 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum