'05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

by Guest 09/04/14, 08:43 pm

Current Rankings include game results from 11/23/13 through Present Date. Game results from the weekend of 11/16-11/17/13 were dropped from the history since the last rankings were posted.

Notes:

1) As stated above, games from the weekend of 11/16-11/17/13 were dropped from the history since the last rankings were posted. If you don't think a team's movement from the last ranking looks appropriate due to their results from this past week, it is likely due to a difference between the new games added vs the old games dropped from the history.

'05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14 05_fbr28

'05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14 05_fbr28

Current Inter-Tier Records
'05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14 05_int24

by TatonkaBurger 11/04/14, 03:02 pm

All right, here are my human rankings for the top 20. Some of you have been asking for a while now so here goes.

There is no scientific or mathematical formula behind it. I use the FBRs to a certain extent but most of it is based on my own eye test and a little gut feeling (or big gut as the case may be). I watch a lot of games and I check the results of those that I don't get to see. I try to base my (humble) opinions on certain results but may ignore others because I may not think they reflect what should have happened – no harm or hurt feelings is intended. Mainly, I do this to generate discussion. So please agree, disagree and post your own adjustments as you see fit. This forum just needs more collective interest.

1. LP Hyypia – no current losses against those below
2. Dallas Rush Voutier – very steady against top boys
3. DT South – 2 recent losses but big game against #1 soon
4. Solar Royal Pulpanek – slightly ahead of #5
5. Sting Diaz – coming on of late
6. Lady Aztecs – loss to #3 (it’s a crime won’t play #1 this season)
7. D’Feeters Black – have beaten those below them
8. Sting Central Parsons – much improved since last season
9. Sting North Garrett – very competitive but can’t get wins
10. LP Gerard – finished the season on a losing skid
11. Solar White Pulpanek – have had tough season but 2 games left
12. Solar Chelsea Abbott – pretty good season against weak 04 teams
13. Sting Scarfone – weak season against mid-pack/weak 04s
14. Sting West Davis – ok season against good competition
15. AFC Black – appear top of CFBAL Gold but#15–#18 are very close
16. Andromeda Rundell – very close #15– #18
17. AFC Red – very close #15– #18
18. Sting East Gray – very close #15– #18
19. NOKC Cole – have had some competitive games against top teams
20. FC Dallas Premier – playing tough competition but need to play more teams above them to prove if belong here

Honorable mentions: Sting Hanlon, Sting Central Sanchez, FC Divas and FC Dallas Roach

Note - Just because the FBR has them, I see there being 3 tiers:
Tier 1 - #1-#6
Tier 2 - #7-#14
Tier 3 - #15-#20

by Guest 11/04/14, 04:04 pm

Teams to watch over the next year;

All Sting Teams - who's going to come out on top. Which teams will fold. Will Diaz go back to Kicks with his team?

DFeeters Black - will this team stay together once they hit select. Sources say Colon won't remain the coach.

Mustangs - Will the twins from the 04 team go to the 05s?

Dallas Rush Winbush - Team to watch for sure. Athletic team with a couple of super fast girls upfront could come around by this time next year. Needs more time playing together. Will this team stay with Dallas Rush?

Dallas Rush Voutier - same question. Will they stay with Rush. Will Voutier coach them once they go Select.

DFeeters Blevins - Solid team. Been together for several years now. Could lose girls to the Dallas area teams.

FC Dallas all - with the creation of the Central Division where do all the girls end up. Will FC Dallas still try to dictate the teams.

by banana kick 12/04/14, 02:41 am

TatonkaBurger wrote:All right, here are my human rankings for the top 20. Some of you have been asking for a while now so here goes.

There is no scientific or mathematical formula behind it. I use the FBRs to a certain extent but most of it is based on my own eye test and a little gut feeling (or big gut as the case may be). I watch a lot of games and I check the results of those that I don't get to see. I try to base my (humble) opinions on certain results but may ignore others because I may not think they reflect what should have happened – no harm or hurt feelings is intended. Mainly, I do this to generate discussion. So please agree, disagree and post your own adjustments as you see fit. This forum just needs more collective interest.

1. LP Hyypia – no current losses against those below
2. Dallas Rush Voutier – very steady against top boys
3. DT South – 2 recent losses but big game against #1 soon
4. Solar Royal Pulpanek – slightly ahead of #5
5. Sting Diaz – coming on of late
6. Lady Aztecs – loss to #3 (it’s a crime won’t play #1 this season)
7. D’Feeters Black – have beaten those below them
8. Sting Central Parsons – much improved since last season
9. Sting North Garrett – very competitive but can’t get wins
10. LP Gerard – finished the season on a losing skid
11. Solar White Pulpanek – have had tough season but 2 games left
12. Solar Chelsea Abbott – pretty good season against weak 04 teams
13. Sting Scarfone – weak season against mid-pack/weak 04s
14. Sting West Davis – ok season against good competition
15. AFC Black – appear top of CFBAL Gold but#15–#18 are very close
16. Andromeda Rundell – very close #15– #18
17. AFC Red – very close #15– #18
18. Sting East Gray – very close #15– #18
19. NOKC Cole – have had some competitive games against top teams
20. Sting West Davis – playing tough competition, ahead of those below

Honorable mentions: FC Dallas Premier Thompson, Sting Hanlon, Sting Central Sanchez, FC Divas and FC Dallas Roach

Note - Just because the FBR has them, I see there being 3 tiers:
Tier 1 - #1-#6
Tier 2 - #7-#14
Tier 3 - #15-#20

Did you mean to rank Sting West Davis both #14 and #20?

by orbitzone2000 12/04/14, 03:22 am

I only disagree with 4 & 5. They should be swapped. Played 4 times the last 2-seasons and Sting Diaz is 2-1-1 against Pulp Royal. Head to Head always wins out. IMHO!!!

Sting West ranked Twice could use some tweaking also. Other than that looks pretty spot on.

by TatonkaBurger 12/04/14, 12:12 pm

banana kick wrote:Did you mean to rank Sting West Davis both #14 and #20?

Definitely a mistake. Thanks for catching it.

by KeeperCommander 12/04/14, 02:30 pm

I do not think D'Feeters Blevins will lose any to Dallas teams.

by TatonkaBurger 14/04/14, 02:30 pm

orbitzone2000 wrote:I only disagree with 4 & 5. They should be swapped. Played 4 times the last 2-seasons and Sting Diaz is 2-1-1 against Pulp Royal. Head to Head always wins out. IMHO!!!

Sting West ranked Twice could use some tweaking also. Other than that looks pretty spot on.

Very good points. I missed the second win against White/Royal but saw the discussion here as to who was actually on the field. But I can see that swap happening.

by banana kick 14/04/14, 06:21 pm

I see it like this. When my 01 was about this age, throughout her U9 and deep into her U10 year -- Slater was pioneering what was to become the FBR, now perfected by BW -- we all posted our rankings, ad nauseam, discussing where we saw each team and why. It was, I'm a little ashamed to admit, a lot of fun, and it did much to reveal how totally nuts we all were. And when all was said and done, it was nothing more than a collection of well-reasoned opinions -- well, a few were well-reasoned anyway. One or two even made an effort to be as objective as possible -- Sweeper comes to mind. Still, it was just opinion. It couldn't have been otherwise.

The advantage of the FBR, besides BW having no clue who any of these girls are, is that it's all results-based. Who beat whom? Is it the whole story? Of course not. How could it be? But it's the least biased measuring stick I've seen to this point.

Awhile back, Tatonka, you said you anticipated constant movement and reshuffling at the top for awhile. Me too. But don't let that stop you. Rank away!

by orbitzone2000 14/04/14, 11:25 pm

soccerdad1972 wrote:Teams to watch over the next year;

All Sting Teams - who's going to come out on top. Which teams will fold. Will Diaz go back to Kicks with his team? I'm pretty sure Sting Diaz is just fine where they are.

DFeeters Black - will this team stay together once they hit select. Sources say Colon won't remain the coach. Who do the sources say will be the Coach?

Mustangs - Will the twins from the 04 team go to the 05s? Heard the Twins are Going to DTS?

Dallas Rush Winbush - Team to watch for sure. Athletic team with a couple of super fast girls upfront could come around by this time next year. Needs more time playing together. Will this team stay with Dallas Rush? Don't know how athletic they are, but shouldn't you know the answer to your second Question since your the team manager right?

Dallas Rush Voutier - same question. Will they stay with Rush. Will Voutier coach them once they go Select. What does it matter what club this team is with? They will Qualify for D-1 no matter what. If they stay together?

DFeeters Blevins - Solid team. Been together for several years now. Could lose girls to the Dallas area teams. Who is this Team? Never heard of them.

FC Dallas all - with the creation of the Central Division where do all the girls end up. Will FC Dallas still try to dictate the teams. FCD is Pretty Irrelevant right now. Will be interesting if they can pull one of the Top 10 teams over, like they Did in the 04 age group.

by TatonkaBurger 15/04/14, 08:41 am

orbitzone2000 wrote:
soccerdad1972 wrote:Dallas Rush Winbush - Team to watch for sure. Athletic team with a couple of super fast girls upfront could come around by this time next year. Needs more time playing together. Will this team stay with Dallas Rush? Don't know how athletic they are, but shouldn't you know the answer to your second Question since your the team manager right?

Yeah, good call Orbit. General, innocuous statements/questions about several teams but one glowing review and projection about one in particular? That's funny. If he's not the manager then definitely a parent.

by TatonkaBurger 15/04/14, 08:47 am

banana kick wrote:I see it like this. When my 01 was about this age, throughout her U9 and deep into her U10 year -- Slater was pioneering what was to become the FBR, now perfected by BW -- we all posted our rankings, ad nauseam, discussing where we saw each team and why. It was, I'm a little ashamed to admit, a lot of fun, and it did much to reveal how totally nuts we all were. And when all was said and done, it was nothing more than a collection of well-reasoned opinions -- well, a few were well-reasoned anyway. One or two even made an effort to be as objective as possible -- Sweeper comes to mind. Still, it was just opinion. It couldn't have been otherwise.

The advantage of the FBR, besides BW having no clue who any of these girls are, is that it's all results-based. Who beat whom? Is it the whole story? Of course not. How could it be? But it's the least biased measuring stick I've seen to this point.

Awhile back, Tatonka, you said you anticipated constant movement and reshuffling at the top for awhile. Me too. But don't let that stop you. Rank away!

Thanks BK. This group has a little over a year before it gets real serious. Might as well have some fun while we wait. If anyone wants to expand it to 25 or even 30 to cover what would be LHD3, have at it. I am happy to include it as we move forward and tweak based on results.

by Guest 15/04/14, 09:10 am

TatonkaBurger wrote:
orbitzone2000 wrote:
soccerdad1972 wrote:Dallas Rush Winbush - Team to watch for sure. Athletic team with a couple of super fast girls upfront could come around by this time next year. Needs more time playing together. Will this team stay with Dallas Rush? Don't know how athletic they are, but shouldn't you know the answer to your second Question since your the team manager right?
Yeah, good call Orbit. General, innocuous statements/questions about several teams but one glowing review and projection about one in particular? That's funny. If he's not the manager then definitely a parent.

Not our manager or parent, but thanks for the compliment.

by TatonkaBurger 22/04/14, 02:49 pm

Back to more important things... There will be another human rankings early next week, after this week's games. There are some good ones.

by Defenseiskey 22/04/14, 03:22 pm

Don't really see your point in doing this with 9 yr old little girls soccer. It's your opinion and means nothing, but if it makes you feel better rank away. I also seriously doubt that you've really seen enough of some of these teams to truly give a good assessment, scores arent always a good indicator of how the game was truly played. Just my 2 cents.

by TatonkaBurger 22/04/14, 03:32 pm

Defenseiskey wrote:Don't really see your point in doing this with 9 yr old little girls soccer. It's your opinion and means nothing, but if it makes you feel better rank away. I also seriously doubt that you've really seen enough of some of these teams to truly give a good assessment, scores arent always a good indicator of how the game was truly played. Just my 2 cents.

I do them to spur on discussion in the 05 forum. I have said that before. There are people who like them. If you don't, don't look at them. Just my 2 cents.

by Defenseiskey 22/04/14, 03:35 pm

If u want to spur on discussion there are other ways to do so. Your opinion doesn't bother me one way or the other, just seems a bit of a time waster to me. You just come across, to me anyways, to like to stir up trouble for some reason. Rank away!!

by orbitzone2000 22/04/14, 03:41 pm

Defenseiskey wrote:If u want to spur on discussion there are other ways to do so. Your opinion doesn't bother me one way or the other, just seems a bit of a time waster to me. You just come across, to me anyways, to like to stir up trouble for some reason. Rank away!!

It's all in good fun SIR!! If you don't like it, You don't have to read it. IMHO!!!

by boilerjoe_96 22/04/14, 03:45 pm

Defenseiskey wrote:You just come across, to me anyways, to like to stir up trouble for some reason.

You just described about 1/2 of the people on the forum...

by Defenseiskey 22/04/14, 03:59 pm

It's not really the rankings itself Orbit, it's the instigater who's doing it. Again, I doubt you or him have seen enough of these teams to give an assessment. Like I said, if you feel better about yourself then rank away. The fbr is enough, why give your opinion on top of that? They are 9!!!

by Guest 22/04/14, 04:02 pm

boilerjoe_96 wrote:
Defenseiskey wrote:You just come across, to me anyways, to like to stir up trouble for some reason.

You just described about 1/2 of the people on the forum...

This is beginning to sound like a thread on the '04 page. PLEEEEEEEEEASE let's not degenerate into that den of iniquity. For the most part our thread is wonderfully boring. I guess that is the joy of having 5-10 teams that can play with one another on pretty much any given day. YAY PARITY!

by KeeperCommander 22/04/14, 04:05 pm

I do believe the last few replies from this thread are exactly why they are done.
Second, I happen to like the rankings. We are not trying to pick a National Champion here, but it does make for interesting conversation.

by TatonkaBurger 22/04/14, 04:09 pm

Defenseiskey wrote:It's not really the rankings itself Orbit, it's the instigater who's doing it. Again, I doubt you or him have seen enough of these teams to give an assessment. Like I said, if you feel better about yourself then rank away. The fbr is enough, why give your opinion on top of that? They are 9!!!

I took a look at your post history. You definitely get a gold star for being a peacemaker. If I say something nice about LP Gerard this time will you put your 2 cents back in your pocket and walk away?

by Defenseiskey 22/04/14, 04:11 pm

It's conversation based on speculation. There are some really good 05 teams, and the game could go either way on any given day. Again, I don't care if you want to participate, just seems a bit of a time waster. Plus, the landscape of teams will more than likely change somewhat in the near future.

by Defenseiskey 22/04/14, 04:13 pm

You can speculate as to which team I'm from all you want. I don't care where you think my team should be ranked. Look at my history all you want too, I just like to call out the obvious.

by Sponsored content

Dallas Texans Soccer Club 2008G * ECRL, NTX	17/04/24, 08:11 am	Dallas Texans East
Dallas Texans field player/keeper opportunities	15/04/24, 11:52 am	Dallas Texans East
Dallas Texans 10G Keeper/field opportunities	15/04/24, 11:44 am	Dallas Texans East
Dallas Texans Soccer 2024/25 ECNL platform opportunities	13/04/24, 11:45 am	Dallas Texans East
Dallas Texans 2024/25 Keeper opportunities	13/04/24, 11:37 am	Dallas Texans East
Fever United 17G NEW! - Keller/Colleyville/Southlake/FTW	11/04/24, 12:55 am	Jumpman
2024 University of North Texas Summer Camps	09/04/24, 09:37 am	meangreen17
>!<JOIN ILLUMINATI IN UGANDA KAMPALA +27672716140	24/03/24, 08:49 am	yunuko
The Complete Soccer Individual Development Program	22/03/24, 07:21 pm	Ben16
Renegades 2014G Pre-ECNL - Blanton	12/03/24, 03:51 pm	FCsoccer1
09 Boys	13/02/24, 03:16 pm	socroc
Looking for 2014b to join our FCD 2014b east team-plano	12/02/24, 11:39 pm	Littleakde
Looking for 2014 boys,to join our FC Dallas 2014B east team	12/02/24, 11:10 pm	Littleakde
Cross City SC 12B (Allen, TX)	12/02/24, 05:10 pm	SkyblueMachine
Cross City SC 13B (Allen, TX)	12/02/24, 05:00 pm	SkyblueMachine
Cross City SC 06B Classic DI & UPSL & CCSC 07B Classic D2	12/02/24, 04:51 pm	SkyblueMachine
Cross City SC 06B (Classic DI & UPSL)	12/02/24, 04:44 pm	SkyblueMachine
ecnl 09	06/02/24, 02:48 pm	smugrr
Fever United 14G Wright - Keller/Colleyville/Southlake/FTW	21/01/24, 12:55 am	Fever United Wright
BVB 2015 Boys - Wylie, Rockwall, Plano	11/01/24, 03:47 pm	wyliesoccer
Dallas Texans 2014G Advanced group forming	03/01/24, 05:41 pm	Dallas Texans East
Dallas Texans 2014G Advanced group forming	03/01/24, 02:44 pm	Dallas Texans East
2015B Team	27/12/23, 12:10 pm	BG1013
Dallas Showcase Keeper guest player opportunity	26/11/23, 01:19 pm	Dallas Texans East
Dallas Showcase Keeper guest player opportunity	26/11/23, 12:00 pm	Dallas Texans East

'05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

'05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14

Re: '05 Girls FBR Rankings - 04-09-14