North Texas Soccer Forum
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.
Latest topics
TOURNAMENT: U90C HILL COUNTRY CLASSIC - AUSTIN - Jan. 24-26Yesterday at 04:37 pmU90C
TOURNAMENT: U90C SPRING KICKOFF - Feb 4-7, 2021Yesterday at 04:36 pmU90C
GAMBIT TOURNAMENT: Gambit Winter Cup Dec 11-1303/12/20, 05:14 pmPITSoccer
TEXAS WINTER CLASSIC - REGISTER NOW03/12/20, 03:39 ammusaisaya
ECNL Super Cup02/12/20, 08:06 pmSoccerupnorth
TOURNAMENT: U90C UPPER 90 CHALLENGE - Dec. 4-602/12/20, 03:46 pmExitmiester
09G Keeper in need of new team02/12/20, 01:17 pmBodhiDalton
Renegades Soccer Club 2013G’s Opportunity’s 02/12/20, 09:40 amRenegades Soccer Club
Renegades 2011G team forming 2020/202102/12/20, 09:35 amRenegades Soccer Club
Congratulations: Cristiano Ronaldo Win The 18th Golden Foot 02/12/20, 01:15 amALEXXXXXXX
Sting 08B - Flower Mound/Highland Village01/12/20, 10:40 pmTitans Bailey
Sting 12b - flower mound/highland village01/12/20, 10:34 pmTitans Bailey
Sting Royal01/12/20, 10:07 pmLongBall
RPL SPRING 2021 (ACADEMY + 2009 11v11 Divisions) Reg. OPEN01/12/20, 03:01 pmU90C
Renegades 12G North - Blanton 01/12/20, 11:07 amtareyncarol
Renegades 11G North - Blanton01/12/20, 10:57 amtareyncarol
Edinson Cavani Will Be Suspend Three Games For His Improper 01/12/20, 12:58 amALEXXXXXXX
08G Keeper needing new team 30/11/20, 09:48 pmSoccerway
Top ‘07 NTX Boys Teams30/11/20, 12:22 pmCtrl Alt de Ligt
ECNL-ECRL 0830/11/20, 10:46 amsmugrr
Club America 2011B palomeque OPEN Tryouts30/11/20, 09:27 amnirav_p_assar
TOURNAMENT: U90C ROUND ROCK OPEN - AUSTIN - Dec. 11-1329/11/20, 10:41 amU90C
DKSC 06G Aranha (Plano, TX 75074)28/11/20, 11:09 amDKSCJA
Tournament Guest Play: Nov & Dec26/11/20, 07:35 pmWhoopsie
High School Soccer Girls 2020-2126/11/20, 05:19 pmanothercrazysoccerdad
Log in

I forgot my password

Be An Athletic Supporter!
Donate and get this nifty tag!

How will D3 schedule be determined?  - Page 3 Pixel
Statistics
We have 14544 registered users
The newest registered user is jpbiv4

Our users have posted a total of 200609 messages in 29530 subjects

How will D3 schedule be determined?

Page 3 of 3 Previous  1, 2, 3

Go down

How will D3 schedule be determined?  - Page 3 Empty Re: How will D3 schedule be determined?

Post by soccerjack on 29/07/14, 09:23 pm

9876 wrote:Bwg, I have been following this tournament for three years.  Every year the committee makes mistakes on the structure of the tournament.   Allowing seeds from week1 to carryover into week2 might be biggest mistake I can remember,  however you are very political as to  assessment  of the committee.   Why is that?  

Also having teams qualify for d1 this year, without having to beat an lhgc quality team(ie some of the 6 wildcards) is a mistake.     Also having 8 pools determine the remaining 10 seeds is a mistake.  You would have been much better eliminating some.teams after week 1, and having less pools to eliminate the risk having strong 2 or 3 seeds who don't qualify because they have a strong 1 seed, while lesser teams qualify simply because they win a much easier bracket

 cheers 

soccerjack
TxSoccer Author
TxSoccer Author

Posts : 994
Join date : 2014-07-11

Back to top Go down

How will D3 schedule be determined?  - Page 3 Empty Re: How will D3 schedule be determined?

Post by soccerjack on 29/07/14, 09:32 pm

10sDad wrote:
soccerjack wrote:
SickofSilliness wrote:
soccerjack wrote:
SickofSilliness wrote:Using bracket placement rewards teams who performed well in their week 1 bracket.

I understand, without cross-bracket play, that LH would not want to reseed based on the first weekend's points (though I question how you defend that . . . and then award D1 status based upon . . . points).  But at least the the bracket placement method allows teams who finished above someone in their bracket to be rewarded with a higher seed.

This year's approach places more weight on LH's original seeding, then on actual performance.

Yes...but doing it this way makes sure the original seeding works out right.

and that is what is most important, right?

Correct. Hopefully next year there will be no surprises.
I told you the LA parents would be happy... Twisted Evil 

It certainly doesn't help fcd central premier..who deserves better than the bracket they got...except for Sunday performance.
soccerjack
soccerjack
TxSoccer Author
TxSoccer Author

Posts : 994
Points : 3360
Join date : 2014-07-11

Back to top Go down

How will D3 schedule be determined?  - Page 3 Empty Re: How will D3 schedule be determined?

Post by Guest on 29/07/14, 10:07 pm

9876 wrote: however you are very political as to  assessment  of the committee.   Why is that?  

Haven't you figured it out yet???  I AM the seeding committee.   Twisted Evil 

Seriously though, go check some of the other '04 threads from this week.  I've gone on record stating that I'm not particularly a fan of the "new" format.

I personally would go back to the "old" format, and furthermore, would modify that format to re-seed the teams for week 2 based on week 1 points.

Now, even though I personally think that would be a more "fair" way to do things, and may change the fortunes of a couple of teams, the data tells me that overall, it would not change things significantly. Both FBR and QT seeding will be ~85% correct at predicting things, you will still have teams every year that felt shafted by their seeding, and you will still have people coming on here every year to complain about the seeding process and the tournament format.

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

How will D3 schedule be determined?  - Page 3 Empty Re: How will D3 schedule be determined?

Post by 9876 on 29/07/14, 10:54 pm

Once again a very politically correct qualified answer, however i will join the crowd and tell your model is very impressive. . I work with "predictive" models in my day job, and most when applied to reality aren't very predictive. I am incredibly impressed by the accuracy of yours, year, after year, after year...... Great job. They not just stand up in lhgcl qualifying, but really are pretty predictive of how teams will fare the entire first year of lhgcl.

9876
TxSoccer Poster
TxSoccer Poster

Posts : 27
Points : 2725
Join date : 2013-07-19

Back to top Go down

How will D3 schedule be determined?  - Page 3 Empty Re: How will D3 schedule be determined?

Post by Guest on 29/07/14, 11:12 pm

It's even better at predicting where teams will be after the fall of U12 season is completed... what does that say???

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

How will D3 schedule be determined?  - Page 3 Empty Re: How will D3 schedule be determined?

Post by Guest on 29/07/14, 11:25 pm

I remember we used the FBR to predict Lebrons return to Cleveland

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

How will D3 schedule be determined?  - Page 3 Empty Re: How will D3 schedule be determined?

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Page 3 of 3 Previous  1, 2, 3

Back to top


 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum