North Texas Soccer Forum
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.
Latest topics
Texans Full Kit Girls YM / YL #15 - FreeYesterday at 12:46 pmbeckeg
Dallas Surf 2008s Forming at PIT Plano - Come Check Us Out!24/01/22, 11:00 pmDallasSurfEast
Solar Covey 12G24/01/22, 08:10 pmskipper
BVB 2014G23/01/22, 12:59 pmaerialb12
BVB 2015/2016B23/01/22, 12:43 pmaerialb12
07 ECNL23/01/22, 10:02 amsmugrr
Tournament Guest Play Opportunity19/01/22, 09:02 amjbj05ntx
FC Dallas - Kounas Looking for Players18/01/22, 09:13 pmbueler13
Dallas Surf 2012s Looking for 1-2 Players18/01/22, 12:33 pmDallasSurfEast
DKSC 12 Monk JGAL18/01/22, 08:20 amDKSC Monk
Open Practices13/01/22, 10:29 pmcmiles0616
Guest Player Opportunity - Winter Cup 2022 Jan. 28-30th 11/01/22, 12:22 pmBEE'S SOCCER
TOURNAMENT: U90C SPRING KICKOFF - Feb 3-6, 202210/01/22, 10:05 amU90C
WINTER CUP The Colony 28th-30th Jan 2009 Boys09/01/22, 06:24 pmTriumph FC
WINTER CUP The Colony 28th-30th Jan 2010 Girls09/01/22, 06:18 pmTriumph FC
Frisco Fusion 13G09/01/22, 11:13 amlonghorns24
Frisco Fusion 12G - 2 New Teams Spring 2022!09/01/22, 11:01 amlonghorns24
Frisco Fusion 11G - Goalie Needed09/01/22, 10:52 amlonghorns24
$15 Friday Night Skills starting this Friday - 1/14/2208/01/22, 07:03 pmDallasSurfEast
WINTER CUP The Colony 28th-30th Jan 2010 Boys08/01/22, 05:04 pmTriumph FC
WINTER CUP The Colony 28th-30th 2012 Girls08/01/22, 04:56 pmTriumph FC
WINTER CUP The Colony 28th-30th Jan 2013 Boys08/01/22, 04:49 pmTriumph FC
WINTER CUP The Colony 28th-30th Jan 2014 Boys 08/01/22, 11:55 amTriumph FC
WINTER CUP The Colony 28th-30th Jan 2008 Boys08/01/22, 11:50 amTriumph FC
WINTER CUP The Colony 28th-30th Jan 2008 Girls08/01/22, 11:44 amTriumph FC
Log in

I forgot my password

Be An Athletic Supporter!
Donate and get this nifty tag!

LHGCL Divisions Pixel
Statistics
We have 15103 registered users
The newest registered user is mccarthy1316@gmail.com

Our users have posted a total of 203531 messages in 30889 subjects

LHGCL Divisions

Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty LHGCL Divisions

Post by smugrr 31/07/18, 09:45 am

As someone new to this, why does Girls Classic set up one large, 20 team first division for the U-11's? They then create two divisions after that year. It seems like this leads to some mismatches when a highly ranked team plays number 19 or 20.

smugrr
TxSoccer Postmaster
TxSoccer Postmaster

Posts : 352
Points : 2275
Join date : 2017-05-10

Back to top Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty Re: LHGCL Divisions

Post by soccerjack 31/07/18, 10:25 am

Because it's downright funny watching 12 yr old girls lose a game 0-8 and get completely demoralized.
soccerjack
soccerjack
TxSoccer Author
TxSoccer Author

Posts : 994
Points : 3777
Join date : 2014-07-11

Back to top Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty Re: LHGCL Divisions

Post by CATX 31/07/18, 10:25 am

From my perspective as a parent of an 07 it gives teams an opportunity that may have had either a great\bad tournament an opportunity to show if they are truly a D1 team after a full season. Seeding, weather etc always gets complained about every QT year so to me the 20 makes sense. It definitely shakes out the contenders after the first season.

CATX
TxSoccer Poster
TxSoccer Poster

Posts : 55
Points : 2076
Join date : 2016-07-21

Back to top Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty Re: LHGCL Divisions

Post by soccerjack 31/07/18, 10:35 am

Stay positive the forecast has been calling for hell to freeze over for a while now.
soccerjack
soccerjack
TxSoccer Author
TxSoccer Author

Posts : 994
Points : 3777
Join date : 2014-07-11

Back to top Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty Re: LHGCL Divisions

Post by Yo 31/07/18, 11:03 am

smugrr wrote:As someone new to this, why does Girls Classic set up one large, 20 team first division for the U-11's? They then create two divisions after that year.  It seems like this leads to some mismatches when a highly ranked team plays number 19 or 20.

There is no good reason. Everybody gets a medal.

Yo
TxSoccer Poster
TxSoccer Poster

Posts : 93
Points : 1497
Join date : 2018-04-16

Back to top Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty Re: LHGCL Divisions

Post by Zizou 31/07/18, 11:20 am

CATX wrote:From my perspective as a parent of an 07 it gives teams an opportunity that may have had either a great\bad tournament an opportunity to show if they are truly a D1 team after a full season. Seeding, weather etc always gets complained about every QT year so to me the 20 makes sense. It definitely shakes out the contenders after the first season.

20 teams in division one the first year of select creates as others have stated “ complete ass woopens” if you look at past results #15 and up have horrible seasons. The top 13 may change a little but not enough to justify 20 teams.

Zizou
TxSoccer Spammer
TxSoccer Spammer

Posts : 2433
Points : 5541
Join date : 2013-11-09

Back to top Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty Re: LHGCL Divisions

Post by Zizou 31/07/18, 11:24 am

A solution might be division one 9,10 play division two 1,2 play-off. Division two 9,10 play Division three 1,2 play-off. Division three 9,10 play re-qualifier.

Zizou
TxSoccer Spammer
TxSoccer Spammer

Posts : 2433
Points : 5541
Join date : 2013-11-09

Back to top Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty Re: LHGCL Divisions

Post by boflc 31/07/18, 03:23 pm

Zizou wrote:A solution might be division one 9,10 play division two 1,2 play-off. Division two 9,10 play Division three 1,2 play-off. Division three 9,10 play re-qualifier.

I believe you're proposing a relegation/promotion play-off.  If so, I'm a big fan of this.  It'd certainly help teams/families comprehend where they actually sit.

Of course, in the 1:1e9 chance something like this ever went into place, they'd have to lock down the whole CPP/ghost thing.  And of course, that'd never happen.  :/

boflc
TxSoccer Poster
TxSoccer Poster

Posts : 45
Points : 2485
Join date : 2015-05-31

Back to top Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty Re: LHGCL Divisions

Post by ekkeeper12 05/08/18, 10:00 am

boflc wrote:
Zizou wrote:A solution might be division one 9,10 play division two 1,2 play-off. Division two 9,10 play Division three 1,2 play-off. Division three 9,10 play re-qualifier.

I believe you're proposing a relegation/promotion play-off.  If so, I'm a big fan of this.  It'd certainly help teams/families comprehend where they actually sit.

Of course, in the 1:1e9 chance something like this ever went into place, they'd have to lock down the whole CPP/ghost thing.  And of course, that'd never happen.  :/
LHGCL used to challenge system like the boys top two and bottom two would play challengers had to win i believe to advance. There was also only a D! and D2 at that time

ekkeeper12
TxSoccer Poster
TxSoccer Poster

Posts : 14
Points : 1670
Join date : 2017-07-27

Back to top Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty Re: LHGCL Divisions

Post by Treinador3 05/08/18, 11:55 am

ekkeeper12 wrote:
boflc wrote:
Zizou wrote:A solution might be division one 9,10 play division two 1,2 play-off. Division two 9,10 play Division three 1,2 play-off. Division three 9,10 play re-qualifier.

I believe you're proposing a relegation/promotion play-off.  If so, I'm a big fan of this.  It'd certainly help teams/families comprehend where they actually sit.

Of course, in the 1:1e9 chance something like this ever went into place, they'd have to lock down the whole CPP/ghost thing.  And of course, that'd never happen.  :/
 LHGCL used to challenge system like the boys top two and bottom two would play challengers had to win i believe to advance. There was also only a D! and D2 at that time

True. And winners of PPL and APL could also get in via a challenge game.

Treinador3
TxSoccer Poster
TxSoccer Poster

Posts : 62
Points : 1971
Join date : 2016-11-14

Back to top Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty Re: LHGCL Divisions

Post by Zizou 05/08/18, 01:56 pm

Treinador3 wrote:
ekkeeper12 wrote:
boflc wrote:
Zizou wrote:A solution might be division one 9,10 play division two 1,2 play-off. Division two 9,10 play Division three 1,2 play-off. Division three 9,10 play re-qualifier.

I believe you're proposing a relegation/promotion play-off.  If so, I'm a big fan of this.  It'd certainly help teams/families comprehend where they actually sit.

Of course, in the 1:1e9 chance something like this ever went into place, they'd have to lock down the whole CPP/ghost thing.  And of course, that'd never happen.  :/
 LHGCL used to challenge system like the boys top two and bottom two would play challengers had to win i believe to advance. There was also only a D! and D2 at that time

True.  And winners of PPL and APL could also get in via a challenge game.

Yeah wishful thinking! They would to go through the qualifier into division three.

Zizou
TxSoccer Spammer
TxSoccer Spammer

Posts : 2433
Points : 5541
Join date : 2013-11-09

Back to top Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty Re: LHGCL Divisions

Post by Treinador3 05/08/18, 01:59 pm

Zizou wrote:
Treinador3 wrote:
ekkeeper12 wrote:
boflc wrote:
Zizou wrote:A solution might be division one 9,10 play division two 1,2 play-off. Division two 9,10 play Division three 1,2 play-off. Division three 9,10 play re-qualifier.

I believe you're proposing a relegation/promotion play-off.  If so, I'm a big fan of this.  It'd certainly help teams/families comprehend where they actually sit.

Of course, in the 1:1e9 chance something like this ever went into place, they'd have to lock down the whole CPP/ghost thing.  And of course, that'd never happen.  :/
 LHGCL used to challenge system like the boys top two and bottom two would play challengers had to win i believe to advance. There was also only a D! and D2 at that time

True.  And winners of PPL and APL could also get in via a challenge game.

Yeah wishful thinking! They would to go through the qualifier into division three.

Nope. A team I coached won PPL, challenged into D2 and eventually wound up D1. There was no D3. Before your time I guess.

Treinador3
TxSoccer Poster
TxSoccer Poster

Posts : 62
Points : 1971
Join date : 2016-11-14

Back to top Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty Re: LHGCL Divisions

Post by Zizou 05/08/18, 10:04 pm

Damn, showing your age a lot has changed.

Zizou
TxSoccer Spammer
TxSoccer Spammer

Posts : 2433
Points : 5541
Join date : 2013-11-09

Back to top Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty Re: LHGCL Divisions

Post by ekkeeper12 06/08/18, 12:28 am

Zizou wrote:Damn, showing your age a lot has changed.
Challenge system was †he norm until about 2006... 2005/2006 when academy started becoming bigger and u11 added d3. Shoot when I started playing competitive soccer d 1 and d2 then Arlington and Plano yes everything was a challenge system. I actually prefer how it used to be lol but will likely never be that way again. The first gk i trained were 95's/96's

ekkeeper12
TxSoccer Poster
TxSoccer Poster

Posts : 14
Points : 1670
Join date : 2017-07-27

Back to top Go down

LHGCL Divisions Empty Re: LHGCL Divisions

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top


 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum