Latest topics
Log in
Be An Athletic Supporter!
Donate and get this nifty tag!
Statistics
We have 15805 registered usersThe newest registered user is markschmidt4
Our users have posted a total of 205176 messages in 31964 subjects
where is this in the rule book
Page 1 of 1 • Share
where is this in the rule book
by Just Curious 26/10/13, 03:29 pm
In a game next to us a player had a rough/dirty play
It looked from our angle a clear push from the back
The offending player was not carded but the ref did send her off the field.
She was only off the field for less than 3 minutes
Never seen this before........
It looked from our angle a clear push from the back
The offending player was not carded but the ref did send her off the field.
She was only off the field for less than 3 minutes
Never seen this before........
Just Curious- TxSoccer Postmaster
- Posts : 155
Points : 4273
Join date : 2013-01-21
Location : Out There
Re: where is this in the rule book
by Guest 26/10/13, 03:37 pm
If it warranted sending her off the field, a card should have been issued. Ive seen that one up close in a game my dd was in.
Break away at goal. Last defender comes in from behind with an elbow to the back of the head. A foul was called, but no card issued.
I asked the ref afterwards why a card wasnt issued. His reason..... "I wont issue a card until they are about U13."
Made zero sense to me.
Break away at goal. Last defender comes in from behind with an elbow to the back of the head. A foul was called, but no card issued.
I asked the ref afterwards why a card wasnt issued. His reason..... "I wont issue a card until they are about U13."
Made zero sense to me.
Guest- Guest
Re: where is this in the rule book
by Joe scafone 26/10/13, 04:16 pm
Sounds like a "lazy" ref not wanting to fill out paperwork or one that was afraid to hurt her feelings?
__________________________________________________
“I’ll make him an offer he can’t refuse.” -- Don Corleone, The Godfather
Joe scafone- TxSoccer Author
- Posts : 748
Points : 6294
Join date : 2009-08-25
Location : Neither here or there
Re: where is this in the rule book
by Gunner9 26/10/13, 04:29 pm
To answer your original question, it is nowhere in the Law, but I have a feeling your question was rhetorical. Refs that make up their own laws drive me crazy.
We had one last week who watched a kid push another kid to the ground with 2 hands to the back. He obviously saw it since he "warned" the offender by saying, "no more pushing". But, he didn't even call a foul. Once again, making up his own Law.
I rarely get upset about judgement calls that differ from my view. But not knowing or applying the Law correctly is inexcusable at any age. For crying out loud, there's only 17 of them.
We had one last week who watched a kid push another kid to the ground with 2 hands to the back. He obviously saw it since he "warned" the offender by saying, "no more pushing". But, he didn't even call a foul. Once again, making up his own Law.
I rarely get upset about judgement calls that differ from my view. But not knowing or applying the Law correctly is inexcusable at any age. For crying out loud, there's only 17 of them.
__________________________________________________
"Futbol is simple, but it is difficult to play simple futbol." Cruyff
Gunner9- TxSoccer Sponsor
- Posts : 642
Points : 5318
Join date : 2011-08-20
Re: where is this in the rule book
by Guest 26/10/13, 04:33 pm
"Refs that make up their own laws drive me crazy. "
AMEN!!
call the game as the rules are written. if 5 red cards are shown and the game is forfeited...FINE WITH ME. Just call it as it is written, we can live with it. don' make up calls that you missed, don't owe a team a call blah blah. don't say play on when some 03 push from behind CALL THE GAME.
Thank you, back to our regularly scheduled programming.....
AMEN!!
call the game as the rules are written. if 5 red cards are shown and the game is forfeited...FINE WITH ME. Just call it as it is written, we can live with it. don' make up calls that you missed, don't owe a team a call blah blah. don't say play on when some 03 push from behind CALL THE GAME.
Thank you, back to our regularly scheduled programming.....
Guest- Guest
Re: where is this in the rule book
by coachdom23 26/10/13, 05:32 pm
That is bad, unless in a college showcase.
I get annoyed when a referee restarts the game after an injury or foul with a goalkeeper punt. That is not a valid restart. Most refs get around it by faking a drop ball with the goalkeeper and no one for the other team. I haven't ref-ed in a couple of years, but I believe that the laws of the game do not set a minimum nor a maximum number of players allowed to participate in a drop ball restart.
I get annoyed when a referee restarts the game after an injury or foul with a goalkeeper punt. That is not a valid restart. Most refs get around it by faking a drop ball with the goalkeeper and no one for the other team. I haven't ref-ed in a couple of years, but I believe that the laws of the game do not set a minimum nor a maximum number of players allowed to participate in a drop ball restart.
coachdom23- TxSoccer Addict
- Posts : 1610
Points : 7576
Join date : 2009-05-17
Re: where is this in the rule book
by ekkeeper1 26/10/13, 11:30 pm
The only time I tend to drop the ball back to the keeper to restart is if the keeper had it in her possession when I stopped play. If they put the ball out of play I will then allow the opposing team to be sporting and play it back. You can have 1 player there for a drop ball or you can have more then 1.coachdom23 wrote:That is bad, unless in a college showcase.
I get annoyed when a referee restarts the game after an injury or foul with a goalkeeper punt. That is not a valid restart. Most refs get around it by faking a drop ball with the goalkeeper and no one for the other team. I haven't ref-ed in a couple of years, but I believe that the laws of the game do not set a minimum nor a maximum number of players allowed to participate in a drop ball restart.
ekkeeper1- TxSoccer Addict
- Posts : 1149
Points : 6708
Join date : 2009-05-27
Re: where is this in the rule book
by Rudder 27/10/13, 04:58 pm
Refs here not enforcing the true Laws of the Game??? Shocking....
Rudder- TxSoccer Poster
- Posts : 92
Points : 5334
Join date : 2010-01-06
Similar topics» interesting book
» JUST4KEEPERSNORTHTEXAS BOOK YOUR SESSIONS NOW
» Interesting book
» interesting book
» interesting book
» JUST4KEEPERSNORTHTEXAS BOOK YOUR SESSIONS NOW
» Interesting book
» interesting book
» interesting book
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
